Which method should an instructor avoid when providing critique based on the provided guidelines?

• A. Engaging in meaningful dialogue
• B. Covering a broad range of topics
• C. Avoiding lengthy critiques
• D. Constructive feedback

Answer: (B)

The correct answer highlights that covering a broad range of topics may detract from the effectiveness of critique. When providing feedback, it is crucial to focus on specific areas to ensure clarity and relevance. A critique that spans too many subjects can overwhelm the recipient and dilute the impact of the feedback. By concentrating on key areas for improvement, the instructor can provide more actionable and targeted guidance. This focused approach helps the learner understand what is most important to address, leading to better outcomes and fostering growth in their work.

Engaging in meaningful dialogue, avoiding lengthy critiques, and providing constructive feedback all support a more effective critique process by promoting understanding and allowing for deeper insights into performance.